Zheng Nai Xin Embroiled in Controversy Over Spiritual Fan Meeting and Cultural Insensitivity

The fan meeting, initially touted as an event where Zheng would offer a form of spiritual or emotional healing to her fans, has been widely criticized. Many have expressed confusion and disappointment, feeling that Zheng's new direction is a departure from the persona and activities they initially supported her for. Critics have labeled her actions as inappropriate and attention-seeking, with some even suggesting that she should refund fans who have supported her in the past. The backlash against Zheng highlights the challenges celebrities face in evolving their public personas and engaging in unconventional activities.

Zheng Nai Xin's decision to host a "healing ceremony" and her subsequent response to the controversy have ignited a broader conversation about the boundaries between celebrities and their fans, as well as the expectations placed on public figures. The audience's reaction to Zheng Nai Xin's response has been mixed, with some viewers expressing skepticism about her apology, labeling it as "insincere" or "trying too hard". Others, however, have come to her defense, believing that she is being "genuine" and "taking responsibility" for the controversy.

On social media, some fans have pointed out that Zheng Nai Xin's apology seemed hastily written and lacked a clear explanation for the incident, leading them to question her sincerity. The debate highlights the complexities of navigating online controversies, particularly when cultural sensitivities and celebrity reputations are at stake. Zheng Nai Xin's controversies have not only stopped at her statements but also include her actions, such as holding a "healing ceremony" with high-priced tickets and claiming to use "divination cards" to interpret energy, which has been criticized as exploiting mysticism to make money.

Her attitude towards Chinese fans has also been questioned, as she previously created a "meng sister" image in China but later criticized Chinese toilets as dirty after returning to Thailand. This statement sparked widespread controversy, with many netizens feeling angry and betrayed. Additionally, Zheng Nai Xin's attendance at a mall event, where she showed disdain for the low attendance of only 70 people, has been questioned, with some accusing her of looking down on her fans for not being supportive enough. These controversies have made many Chinese fans feel disappointed and hurt, feeling that Zheng Nai Xin has "forgotten her roots" and ignored the support and help she received from Chinese fans.

The controversies surrounding Zheng Nai Xin highlight the contradictions faced by foreign artists in balancing their native market with cultural respect. While relying on the Chinese fan economy, they may also trigger backlash due to cultural insensitivity. When fans invest emotional and economic support but are met with "betrayal," it reflects the artist's failure to maintain a two-way "emotional contract." Ultimately, Zheng Nai Xin's controversies serve as a warning to cross-national artists: when commercial interests and emotional responsibilities are imbalanced, even the best starting point can become a dead end.