Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay updated with the latest news and trends.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Browse

Categories, quick links and the newsletter.

Quick Links

Newsletter

Get the latest updates

Subscribe to our newsletter to stay informed about trending topics.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

T
Life Stories

Nanjing's 'Zero-Yuan' Noodle Shop Now Limits Free Bowls After Neighbors' Backlash

Two Nanjing noodle shops spent three weeks serving free noodles to anyone who queued — then lost half their neighbors' business to the queues. On November 13 the shops scrapped the open invitation and now serve free bowls only to four groups, disabled people among them.

For three weeks, two noodle shops in Nanjing did something almost no restaurant in China does: they charged nothing, for anyone. No payment QR code at the counter, no means test, no questions — anyone who queued got a free bowl of vegetarian noodles. The "zero-yuan noodle shops" went viral as a pure kindness story, then went viral again as an argument. On Baidu's hot board, where the question charted as "is the free noodle charity, or is it making a mess?", the shops' own answer arrived on November 13: the open invitation is gone. Free noodles are now limited to four groups, disabled people among them.

What broke the mood was the row of shops next door. A ramen-shop owner told Knews, the news app of Shanghai's broadcaster, that his family took over their store in April and had not yet recouped the cost when the free-noodle queues began — lines long enough to block his own door. The noodle shop's owner came over and paid him 10,000 yuan in compensation, which the ramen owner tallied against the damage: "For those first days, nobody walked in at all... and after all these weeks, what does 10,000 yuan amount to?" His business, he said, had fallen by nearly half.

The neighbors' accounts stacked up. A vendor of nine years told Knews his takings had gone from just over 1,000 yuan a day to five or six hundred; he and his wife worked the stall in 24-hour shifts, from 7 a.m. to 3 or 4 the next morning, and after rent were left with about 100 yuan — less than the mortgage. Another shopkeeper, a single mother of three, said she was preparing to transfer her store: doing good is good, she allowed, but in her view the free bowls were not reaching the people who needed them — in a big city, how many able-bodied people genuinely cannot afford to eat? Her complaint was blunter: plenty of men under fifty, perfectly fit, now ate free and "lay flat" — 躺平, the slang for opting out — instead of working.

The regulars pushed back just as hard. A laid-off worker interviewed by Knews, in a clip that drew more than 2,000 likes, was furious on the owner's behalf: "Someone has to speak up for him! Most of the people queuing are sanitation workers, the elderly, the disabled." An 80-year-old regular put it more simply: she was too old to cook, so she came for a bowl. Local market-supervision officials, asked to rule, declined to see a crime: charity is not illegal.

The shops' fix — a capped list of eligible groups — is an old dilemma in a new shape, and Chinese readers immediately reached for the classic precedent: famine-relief granaries that mixed sand into the porridge, so that only the truly desperate would queue for it and the fed would stay home. A free meal with no screen, the Baidu summary of the row concluded, drew mostly people hunting a freebie rather than the hard-up. The sand is gone from the porridge now. What Nanjing's noodle shops are left testing is whether generosity can be sorted without insulting the people it was meant for.