Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay updated with the latest news and trends.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Browse

Categories, quick links and the newsletter.

Quick Links

Newsletter

Get the latest updates

Subscribe to our newsletter to stay informed about trending topics.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

T
Health

Why a Chengdu Surgeon Telling Patients to Skip the Soup Has 2 Million Followers

A ward video of West China Hospital orthopedic surgeon Ma Jun urging a hospitalized teenager to keep studying has made him the latest star of China's medical-science-communication boom — and his nutrition advice, eat the egg, skip the bone broth, keeps colliding with what Chinese families believe about food.

The video that made Dr. Ma Jun famous this week was shot in a hospital ward in Chengdu, and it contains no medicine at all. It shows an orthopedic surgeon at West China Hospital perched beside the bed of a high-school junior, urging him — earnestly, at length, in thick Sichuan-accented Mandarin — to keep up with his studies. Chengdu's official city account posted the clip, and it has been reposted more than 700 times and liked more than 3,500. The line commenters kept repeating was a diagnosis of the whole genre: "This is the kind of medical advice you can actually take in."

It is not Ma Jun's first viral round. Earlier clips showed him lecturing elderly patients on food: eat more eggs, drink less soup, eat more meat. That last one — a economics reporter's post quotes his formulation "eggs are the best-value quality protein there is" — is where his bedside talk collides with several generations of Chinese family belief. In the folk dietetics most patients grow up with, soup is the nourishing thing; a bone broken or a body run down calls for long-simmered broth, ideally from bones, to build it back. Hospital nutritionists have spent years explaining that the calcium stays in the bones rather than the broth, and that the protein a healing body needs is in the meat, not the water it was boiled in. Ma Jun's version simply says it, in dialect, to the patient's face.

The stories fans trade read like parables with the same moral. One commenter recalled his counsel to a devout Buddhist patient with a bad knee: Buddha knows all things — including your knee pain — so there is no need to kneel or sit cross-legged to chant; sit in a chair, and Buddha will understand. Amitabha. It is a joke that works because it refuses to fight the patient's beliefs and instead reroutes them around the injury. Chengdu officials' own write-up credits him with using "plain language to take apart medical knowledge and humor to dilute the anxiety of illness," and with clinical skill that keeps patients listening once the joke lands.

The setting explains the appetite. West China Hospital is one of the largest medical centers in the world, its clinics famously oversubscribed; the ordinary Chinese outpatient gets a few minutes with a doctor who has a corridor of people behind them. Against that baseline, a surgeon who will explain, at length and in the patient's own dialect, why grandma's soup is not helping the bone, is rare enough to trend. His official title is leader of the joint-surgery group in orthopedics; his side job, by follower count, is one of China's bigger medical-science-communication careers, with more than two million people reading a hospital corridor.

None of the advice itself is new — the egg over the broth is standard nutrition, and has been for years. What is new is the messenger's reach: two million followers for a man whose day job is knee and hip replacements, and a ward pep talk that became the week's most-shared piece of "medical advice" in China.